Payrolling benefits in kind in 2027: What employers need to set up now

1. What is mandatory payrolling of benefits in kind and how does it work?
2. What’s changing after the P11D replacement in 2027?
3. How will BIK payrolling work in practice, and what will change for payroll teams?
4. What should employers consider for managing benefits in kind through payroll?
5. Preparing your software for payrolling benefits in kind
6. PeopleHR makes payrolling expenses and benefits easy

Mandatory payrolling of benefits in kind means that instead of using annual forms, employers must process taxable benefits throughout the year as employees are paid. This means that payrolling expenses and benefits will become a real-time model, where tax is collected gradually through payroll rather than being reconciled later.

While the aim is to simplify reporting and reduce administration, this change also places greater pressure on payroll systems and the quality of the data feeding into them. Benefits that are currently handled separately through annual reporting may need to be built directly into payroll processes.

The move away from annual reporting changes the timing, systems and processes behind how benefits are managed and taxed. Let's look at some of the biggest differences that employers will need to prepare for.

Key differences between P11D reporting and payrolling

Historically, employers used a P11D form to report taxable benefits after the financial year had ended. Employees would then see changes to tax codes or adjustments made later to recover any tax owed.

Under the new BIK payrolling system, taxable values will be rolled into payroll processing throughout the year. Rather than reviewing benefits after the event, employers will need systems that can process information accurately during each pay cycle, shifting from retrospective to ongoing reporting.

Benefits excluded from payrolling rules

Not every benefit will necessarily follow the same process. Different rules can apply depending on the type of benefit and how it is taxed. While common benefits such as company cars and private medical insurance are expected to move into payroll, employer-provided accommodation and beneficial loans are currently excluded from mandatory payrolling rules.

Employers offering different employee benefits should review how each one is currently managed, and how they should be processed going forwards. While many common benefits are expected to move into payroll, some categories may continue to require separate treatment or additional reporting requirements.

Timeline and key dates for the transition

Although April 2027 may seem distant, payroll system changes often take longer than expected to implement and test. Delays in preparation can also make it harder to identify system gaps and reporting issues as deadlines approach.

Planning should begin well before your next payroll year-end, especially if your payroll data is fed by multiple systems. Waiting too long can create pressure around software updates, employee communications and process changes, which can lead to rushed implementation decisions.

The practical impact of these changes will be felt most by payroll teams. Let's look at how payrolling expenses and benefits will work in practice, and what this means for your teams.

Moving reporting into real time through payroll

The biggest operational shift is timing. Instead of reporting benefit information after the tax year, employers will need to process this information throughout the year as employees are paid.

This means that payroll teams will rely more heavily on data arriving at the right time and in the right format. An effective RTI (real-time information) payroll process becomes increasingly important, helping to minimise reporting delays or inaccuracies that can affect employee tax calculations.

Adding taxable benefits to payslips each pay period

Employees may also notice changes to their payslips. Rather than seeing tax adjustments later through amended tax codes, their taxable benefit values will be clearly visible throughout the year.

This may create confusion initially if employees notice changes in net pay without understanding why. Payroll teams should expect more questions and be prepared to explain how benefit values are calculated and applied.

Reporting benefits via Full Payment Submission (FPS)

The reporting route itself is also set to change. Benefit information will become part of regular payroll submissions rather than annual reporting exercises, helping HMRC to collect tax on benefits in real time throughout the year.

The Full Payment Submission (FPS) process will become even more important because payroll submissions will contain a broader range of information. When reporting happens continuously, errors or inconsistencies could have wider implications, potentially affecting employee tax calculations, reporting accuracy and overall payroll compliance.

Class 1A NICs and cash flow implications

The upcoming changes won’t only affect administration; they can also affect cash flow and budgeting. The timing of payments can affect forecasting and financial planning, particularly for larger employers with substantial benefit schemes.

Because benefit reporting will be integrated into payroll, employers may need to reassess how statutory payroll deductions and related liabilities are managed throughout the year. This may create additional pressure on payroll teams to maintain accurate reporting and closely monitor liabilities throughout each pay cycle.

Processing benefits in kind through payroll creates new operational decisions for employers. There are also practical risks and system considerations that can affect how the transition works in practice. Let’s take a look.

Deciding whether to roll out voluntary payrolling now

Some employers already have the option to payroll benefits voluntarily before mandatory changes arrive. Starting earlier can provide valuable time to test processes and understand system requirements. However, making changes too soon without the right preparation can introduce complexity, especially if systems and internal processes aren't fully aligned.

Managing double taxation during the transition

One of the more challenging transition risks is accidental double taxation. This can happen if benefit values remain reflected in historic tax code arrangements while also being processed through payroll. During any transition period, payroll teams will need to monitor reporting carefully to avoid duplicated tax.

Reviewing payroll systems and internal processes

Payroll software capability will become increasingly important as reporting shifts into payroll. Reviewing whether your existing solution can manage benefit calculations, data transfers and reporting requirements is essential before you make any changes to your processes. Many employers currently use separate systems across HR, payroll and benefits administration, and may want to consider moving to a single integrated system for ease of use.

It’s important to prepare early, giving your business plenty of time to make sure everything is working as it should before the deadline. Let's look at the practical actions that employers should start taking now to BIK payrolling.

1. Make sure benefits are accurate and up to date

Your organisation’s payroll reports are only as accurate as the information feeding into them. As businesses move to continuous reporting, inconsistencies and outdated information can have a significant impact. Make sure to review existing benefits and check their accuracy before using your existing data for monthly processing of benefits in kind.

2. Review how you’re currently payrolling expenses and benefits

Understanding your current process helps to highlight where future gaps may appear. If some information is handled manually, stored in spreadsheets or managed outside payroll, additional work may be required before systems can support ongoing reporting. This will help to ensure that reporting remains accurate, consistent and fully aligned with changing processes.

3. Configure the benefits for BIK payrolling within your system

Benefits need to be structured in a way that payroll systems can process consistently. This could include assigning categories, setting calculation rules, or ensuring that benefit information can flow correctly through payroll processes. Completing this configuration work early on can help to reduce issues later.

4. Train payroll teams on processing benefits in kind through payroll

New reporting requirements often mean new responsibilities. Payroll teams should understand how benefits in kind through payroll will affect processing, reporting and employee support. Training helps to build confidence before new processes become mandatory.

5. Test the new payrolling benefits in kind process before going live

Testing provides an opportunity to identify issues before employees are affected. Running parallel payroll exercises or test scenarios can reveal gaps in calculations, workflows or reporting processes without impacting real employee payments. Fixing problems at this stage is much easier than correcting live payroll issues.

6. Communicate the changes and their impact to your employees

Employees may notice changes to payslips, tax treatment or how benefits appear. Clear communication helps to reduce confusion and avoid unnecessary payroll queries. Explaining these changes early on also helps employees understand what to expect and minimise any panic.

7. Consider external support or new payroll software if necessary

Not every payroll system will be ready for the transition. If their existing systems lack flexibility, some organisations may choose to outsource their payroll requirements or explore new software solutions. Reviewing options now creates more time to make informed decisions rather than rushed changes later on.

Mandatory changes to payrolling benefits in kind will affect reporting processes, payroll systems, and the way that employers manage benefits in kind through payroll. While 2027 may feel far away, early preparation gives organisations more time to review systems, identify gaps, and build stronger processes before reporting becomes mandatory.

The right cloud-based payroll software can help to reduce complexity by bringing payroll, reporting and people data together in one place. PeopleHR helps employers to manage payroll processes more effectively and adapt to changing requirements with tools designed to support growing businesses.

Watch a 4-minute demo or contact our payroll experts to find out more about how we can support your transition ahead of April 2027.

You might be interested in:

If you enjoyed this article, you may be interested in reading:

1. What is a P11D form? Guide for employers and upcoming changes
2. FPS and EPS payroll: What are they and what’s the difference?
3. Payroll year end checklist: Steps and guidance for SMBs